Stephen Jones welcomes the Rugby Paper's, Nick Caine, The Sunday Times, Nigel Botherway and red top favourite, Adam Hathaway.
They discuss the passion and precision of Scotland and where "flummoxed, static and poor" England go next, after being dominated.
The panel also detail the changes they would make for England. Do Hartley, Brown and Robshaw survive? Or does the entire game plan need an overhaul?
The rest of the weekend is reviewed and players of the weekend picked.