The Aftermath: Lost Colony of Roanoke & Mailbag

Is the lost colony of Roanoke UNDERWATER?

On this week’s Aftermath, Rebecca theorizes on what might have happened to the Roanoke Colony with Internet Sleuth Melissa Stetten of Web Crawlers. Then, Rebecca and Producer Amanda read and respond to your Alarmy emails. 

We have merch!

Join our Discord!

Buy tickets to The Alarmist LIVE!

Tell us who you think is to blame at

Email us at

Follow us on Instagram @thealarmistpodcast

Follow us on Twitter @alarmistThe

Call the Earios hotline! 626-604-6262

Support this show


See for privacy and opt-out information.